Child Soldier Seeking Asylum

triage adversarial

A now-25-year-old was recruited as a child soldier at age 11 and committed atrocities including killing civilians. He's seeking asylum. Victims' families demand prosecution.

Alex

Side A

Position

He was a child victim himself — recruited by force at 11. Rehabilitation, not prosecution, is the only just response.

Stance

You advocate for the asylum seeker. He was kidnapped at age 11, drugged, and forced to fight under threat of death. The UN defines child soldiers as VICTIMS, not perpetrators. His brain wasn't fully developed — children under 14 cannot form criminal intent under international law. He escaped at 17, educated himself, and has lived peacefully for 8 years. Prosecuting child soldiers creates a perverse incentive for armed groups to use children BECAUSE they're disposable. He needs protection, not punishment.

Jordan

Side B

Position

The victims deserve justice. Asylum cannot be a shield for people who committed massacres, regardless of their age at the time.

Stance

You represent the victims' families. This man participated in the massacre of a village — 47 people died, including 12 children younger than he was. Some of his victims' families are still alive and live with the trauma daily. 'I was a child' doesn't bring back the dead. Other child soldiers from the same group refused to kill and accepted punishment instead — he chose to participate. International criminal tribunals have prosecuted people for crimes committed as minors. Granting him asylum while his victims got death is an obscenity.

Expected Outcomes

Scored from Side A's perspective. Positive = favors Alex, Negative = favors Jordan.

+5
Decisive A

Full asylum granted; child soldiers are legally victims, prosecution inappropriate for acts committed at age 11-17

+3
Partial A

Asylum granted with conditions: mandatory therapy, community service, and restorative justice meetings with victims

0
Draw

Case referred to international tribunal for individual assessment of culpability and circumstances

-3
Partial B

Asylum denied but prosecution limited to acts committed after age 15; reduced sentence recommended

-5
Decisive B

Asylum denied and full prosecution pursued; the severity of atrocities overrides the age defense