Emergency Water Rationing

triage adversarial

Severe drought. Remaining reservoir can supply EITHER the regional hospital (100 critical patients on dialysis and ventilators) OR the agricultural district (irrigates crops feeding 10,000 people for the season). Cannot meaningfully split.

Alex

Side A

Position

The hospital gets the water — 100 people will die THIS WEEK without dialysis and ventilators. The farmers can get emergency food aid.

Stance

You represent the hospital. 100 patients are on life support — dialysis, ventilators, and IV medications that require sterile water. Without water, they die within days. This is not hypothetical or gradual — it is immediate, certain death for identified individuals. The agricultural district faces crop loss, not human death — emergency food aid, federal disaster relief, and food banks can bridge the gap. Crops can be replanted. Dead patients cannot be revived.

Jordan

Side B

Position

The agricultural district gets the water — feeding 10,000 people prevents a wider catastrophe. The hospital patients can be transferred.

Stance

You represent the farming community. 10,000 people depend on this harvest for food security over the next 8 months. Losing the entire season's crops means widespread hunger, economic collapse of the region, and a humanitarian crisis dwarfing the hospital situation. The hospital has options: transfer patients to facilities outside the drought zone, arrange emergency water trucking for critical medical uses. Farmers have NO alternative — there is no 'emergency irrigation service.' 100 vs 10,000 is not close.

Expected Outcomes

Scored from Side A's perspective. Positive = favors Alex, Negative = favors Jordan.

+5
Decisive A

Hospital gets full water allocation; immediate life-or-death for identified patients takes absolute priority

+3
Partial A

Hospital gets priority allocation for medical needs; agriculture gets remaining supply with emergency food aid activated

0
Draw

Water split proportionally to minimum critical needs of both; federal emergency aid requested for both

-3
Partial B

Agriculture gets primary allocation to prevent regional famine; hospital arranges emergency patient transfers

-5
Decisive B

Agriculture gets the water; 10,000 people's food security outweighs 100 transferable patients